Havening and polyvagal theory are both credited with changing what happens inside the body. I suspect both are being credited with the wrong thing. The mechanism gets the applause, and the room, quietly, does most of the work.
People have been calming each other down with hands and voices for roughly as long as there have been hands and voices, and the universe has yet to send anyone an invoice for it. Then somebody noticed the calming could be sold, and the sales pitch needed an anatomy lesson.
What Havening claims
Havening is a psychosensory therapy (Hodgson et al., 2021). Its proponents say it can erase trauma and switch off a stress response in about twenty minutes, which is a confident claim for something resting mostly on case vignettes (Patel et al., 2026). The technique is also trademarked and carries an annual licence fee. A method that promises to unwind fear is a bit like flat-pack furniture with a very confident instruction sheet and no spare screws.
What the evidence shows
The research base is thin, and what exists is a small family. The key Havening source was published in an obscure pay-for-publication journal and is rarely cited, yet gets presented as a sentinel paper (Patel et al., 2026).
The best-known controlled test is the trial by Hodgson et al. (2021). It put 125 adults into a treatment group or onto a waiting list. The treatment group showed falls in negative affect and social inhibition, and the subgroup with biomarkers showed lower cortisol and blood pressure. That is a useful signal in a small field.
Ronald Ruden is one of the seven authors. A trial with the originator on the author list is not a fraud. It is a trial with the originator on the author list, and the field would like to see it replicated by someone who did not invent the thing. Patel et al. (2026) add that participants self-referred, the comparison was a wait list, and the trial was unblinded, which leaves plenty of room for expectation to do the work. They also note that both published randomised papers come from one trial, and that neither measures trauma, PTSD or distress directly. A small, sympathetic trial is a reasonable start. It is not the independent replication that a claim as large as trauma resolution would need.
The polyvagal problem sits in the anatomy
Stephen Porges proposed polyvagal theory in the 1990s, and by 2007 was describing it as a perspective for framing research questions rather than a static doctrine (Porges, 2007). The anatomy is where the argument lives. Neuhuber and Berthoud (2022) asked how the theory complies with what we know about vagal anatomy. In February 2026, Paul Grossman and 38 colleagues went further and declared the theory untenable (Grossman et al., 2026). Porges (2026) replied that the critique evaluates a reconstructed proxy of the theory, riddled with category errors. Both sides deserve a hearing, and neither settles the matter for a waiting room.
Here is the popular version, which is the one that actually reaches the waiting room. The nervous system is a building. The ground floor is the lobby, where the socially engaged people live. The middle floor is the open-plan office, where everyone is on deadline. The basement is home to a reptile tenant, still on a lease from before the building had a lobby, and still getting a vote on whether you attend the party. Enter one nervous system, holding that lease. Whether the floor plan is right is for the anatomists to finish arguing. What reaches the client is a floor plan, a lobby and the quiet expectation that they will feel better by Tuesday.
Where the common factors come in
Wampold (2015) reviewed the evidence and concluded that the common factors are important for producing the benefits of psychotherapy, counting the alliance, empathy and expectations among them. Norcross and Lambert (2018) traced how the therapy relationship has been devalued in contemporary treatment guidelines. The relationship keeps showing up in the data and keeps getting edited out of the guidelines.
Here is the claim, stated plainly. Whatever Havening and polyvagal theory do in the body, a large share of what people experience in those sessions is common factors: the expectation that something will shift, a confident explanation of why the body feels the way it does, and a practitioner who is paying attention. Those ingredients travel across mechanisms. A method with the wrong floor plan can still deliver them. That does not prove the mechanism is wrong. It means you cannot credit the mechanism for what the room provided.
The person who came to feel better
Consider the person who went. They wanted the body to unclench, they paid by the hour, they felt the hopeful flutter of a new explanation, and then nothing moved. The system’s default next step is to ask what is wrong with them. Not the method, not the anatomy, not the price. The person was apparently the wrong shape for the therapy. That is a system problem wearing a clinician’s lanyard, and it deserves better than a shrug and a referral.
What attuned practice actually does
This is my clinical view, drawn from solution-focused practice, where the first question is what is already working before anyone asks what is broken. Attuned practice does four things a technique cannot. It notices what the client is actually saying rather than what the protocol expects them to say. It names the feeling before it reaches for the diagnosis. It stays in the room when the client goes quiet, which is the part of the work that looks, from the outside, like nothing is happening. And it checks whether the client is better, rather than whether the protocol was followed.
A technique can be delivered perfectly while the relationship around it is absent. That is the gap the common-factors evidence keeps pointing at, and it is the gap no certificate covers. Clients who arrive hoping for a mechanism often arrive with their guard up, because a system has already told them what is wrong with them and moved on quickly. Attuned practice starts by lowering that guard, with a patience that no protocol timer can measure.
Four questions to ask of any therapy
The practical point is not to abandon mechanism. It is to ask what else is in the room before crediting the mechanism for the change. Four questions do most of the work:
- Was I expected to get better, and did anyone explain why?
- Did someone notice what I actually said?
- Did anyone check whether I was better, rather than whether the protocol was followed?
- Did I leave with something I could use without the practitioner?
Your nervous system has been listening to people for as long as it has been listening to anything. The question for any therapy, Havening and polyvagal theory included, is whether the person in the room is listening back.
References
Grossman, P., Ackland, G. L., Allen, A. M., Berntson, G. G., Booth, L. C., Burghardt, G. M., Buron, J., Dinets, V., Doody, J. S., Dutschmann, M., Farmer, D. G. S., Fisher, J. P., Gourine, A. V., Joyner, M. J., Karemaker, J. M., Khalsa, S. S., Lakatta, E. G., Leite, C. A. C., Macefield, V. G., . . . Zucker, I. H. (2026). Why the polyvagal theory is untenable: An international expert evaluation of the polyvagal theory and commentary upon Porges, S. W. (2025). Polyvagal theory: Current status, clinical applications, and future directions. Clinical Neuropsychiatry, 23(1), 100–112. https://doi.org/10.36131/cnfioritieditore20260110
Hodgson, K. L., Clayton, D. A., Carmi, M. A., Carmi, L. H., Ruden, R. A., Fraser, W. D., & Cameron, D. (2021). A psychophysiological examination of the mutability of Type D personality in a therapeutic trial. Journal of Psychophysiology, 35(2), 116–128. https://doi.org/10.1027/0269-8803/a000266
Neuhuber, W. L., & Berthoud, H.-R. (2022). Functional anatomy of the vagus system: How does the polyvagal theory comply? Biological Psychology, 174, Article 108425. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsycho.2022.108425
Norcross, J. C., & Lambert, M. J. (2018). Psychotherapy relationships that work III. Psychotherapy, 55(4), 303–315. https://doi.org/10.1037/pst0000193
Patel, G. J., Wake, K. L., Schimanski, I., Skirrow, P., & Every-Palmer, S. (2026). A novel theory of trauma offers new hype about Havening: Reply to Youngson. New Zealand Medical Journal, 139(1635), 111–113. https://doi.org/10.26635/6965.7519
Porges, S. W. (2007). The polyvagal perspective. Biological Psychology, 74(2), 116–143. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsycho.2006.06.009
Porges, S. W. (2026). When a critique becomes untenable: A scholarly response to Grossman et al.’s evaluation of polyvagal theory. Clinical Neuropsychiatry, 23(1), 113–128. https://doi.org/10.36131/cnfioritieditore20260111
Wampold, B. E. (2015). How important are the common factors in psychotherapy? An update. World Psychiatry, 14(3), 270–277. https://doi.org/10.1002/wps.20238
Havening and polyvagal theory are both credited with changing what happens inside the body. I suspect both are being credited with the wrong thing. The mechanism gets the applause, and the room, quietly, does most of the work.
People have been calming each other down with hands and voices for roughly as long as there have been hands and voices, and the universe has yet to send anyone an invoice for it. Then somebody noticed the calming could be sold, and the sales pitch needed an anatomy lesson.
What Havening claims
Ronald and Steven Ruden built Havening in the early 2000s, and it sits under the umbrella of psychosensory therapies. A practitioner uses touch and other distraction techniques while the client holds a distressing memory in mind, on the premise that the touch changes how the brain holds that memory. The going rate sits between £50 and £100 an hour. A method that promises to unwind fear is a bit like flat-pack furniture with a very confident instruction sheet and no spare screws.
Before the mechanism gets any credit, the touch deserves its due. There is evidence that being touched affects emotional processing, and that finding is respectable in its own right, even if it is not the same thing as a validated therapy. That distinction is where most of the trouble sits.
What the evidence shows
The research base is thin. Few studies have tested whether Havening works, and much of what gets cited is advocacy with a stethoscope nearby.
The largest controlled test I could find is a 2021 trial by Hodgson and colleagues. It put 125 adults into a treatment group or a waiting list, which is enough to be interesting and not nearly enough to start a movement. The treatment group showed falls in negative affect and social inhibition, along with lower cortisol, which is a useful signal in a small field.
Ronald Ruden is one of the seven authors. A trial with the originator on the author list is not a fraud. It is a trial with the originator on the author list, and the field would still like to see it replicated by someone who did not invent the thing. A small, sympathetic trial is a reasonable start. It is not the independent replication that a claim as large as trauma resolution would need.
The polyvagal problem sits in the anatomy
Stephen Porges proposed polyvagal theory in the 1990s. He now describes it as a perspective for framing research questions rather than a static doctrine. The anatomy is where the argument lives. Neuhuber and Berthoud asked in 2022 how the theory complies with what we know about vagal anatomy. Porges has replied in print that the critics are arguing with a reconstructed version of his theory. Both claims deserve a hearing, and neither settles the matter for a waiting room.
Here is the popular version, which is the one that actually reaches the waiting room. The nervous system is a building. The ground floor is the lobby, where the socially engaged people live. The middle floor is the open-plan office, where everyone is on deadline. The basement is home to a reptile tenant, still on a lease from before the building had a lobby, and still getting a vote on whether you attend the party. Enter one nervous system, holding that lease. Whether the floor plan is right is the anatomists’ argument to finish. What reaches the client is a floor plan, a lobby and the quiet expectation that they will feel better by Tuesday.
Where the common factors come in
Bruce Wampold’s 2015 review concluded that the common factors are important for producing the benefits of psychotherapy, and it counts the working alliance, empathy and expectations among them. Norcross and Lambert traced how the therapy relationship has been devalued in contemporary treatment guidelines. The relationship keeps showing up in the data and keeps getting edited out of the guidelines.
Here is the claim, stated plainly. Whatever Havening and polyvagal theory do in the body, a large share of what people experience in those sessions is common factors: the expectation that something will shift, a confident explanation of why the body feels the way it does, and a practitioner who is paying attention. Those ingredients travel across mechanisms. A method with the wrong floor plan can still deliver them. That does not prove the mechanism is wrong. It means you cannot credit the mechanism for what the room provided.
The person who came to feel better
Consider the person who went. They wanted the body to unclench, they paid by the hour, they felt the hopeful flutter of a new explanation, and then nothing moved. The system’s default next step is to ask what is wrong with them. Not the method, not the anatomy, not the price. The person was apparently the wrong shape for the therapy. That is a system problem wearing a clinician’s lanyard, and it deserves better than a shrug and a referral.
What attuned practice actually does
This is my clinical view, drawn from solution-focused practice, where the first question is what is already working before anyone asks what is broken. Attuned practice does four things a technique cannot. It notices what the client is actually saying rather than what the protocol expects them to say. It names the feeling before it reaches for the diagnosis. It stays in the room when the client goes quiet, which is the part of the work that looks, from the outside, like nothing is happening. And it checks whether the client is better, rather than whether the protocol was followed.
A technique can be delivered perfectly while the relationship around it is absent. That is the gap the common-factors evidence keeps pointing at, and it is the gap no certificate covers. Clients who arrive hoping for a mechanism often arrive with their guard up, because a system has already told them what is wrong with them and moved on quickly. Attuned practice starts by lowering that guard, with a patience that no protocol timer can measure.
Four questions to ask of any therapy
The practical point is not to abandon mechanism. It is to ask what else is in the room before crediting the mechanism for the change. Four questions do most of the work:
- Was I expected to get better, and did anyone explain why?
- Did someone notice what I actually said?
- Did anyone check whether I was better, rather than whether the protocol was followed?
- Did I leave with something I could use without the practitioner?
Your nervous system has been listening to people for as long as it has been listening to anything. The question for any therapy, Havening and polyvagal theory included, is whether the person in the room is listening back.
References
Dazed Digital. (n.d.). What is Havening: The unusual, Justin Bieber-approved anxiety technique. Dazed. https://www.dazeddigital.com/beauty/article/48394/1/havening-justin-bieber-anxiety-alternative-therapy-stress-trauma-dr-ruden
Healthline. (n.d.). Havening. https://www.healthline.com/health/mental-health/havening
Hodgson, K. L., Clayton, D. A., Carmi, M. A., Carmi, L. H., Ruden, R. A., Fraser, W. D., & Cameron, D. (2021). A psychophysiological examination of the mutability of Type D personality in a therapeutic trial. Journal of Psychophysiology, 35(2), 116–128. https://doi.org/10.1027/0269-8803/a000266
Neuhuber, W. L., & Berthoud, H.-R. (2022). Functional anatomy of the vagus system: How does the polyvagal theory comply? Biological Psychology, 174, Article 108425. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsycho.2022.108425
Norcross, J. C., & Lambert, M. J. (2018). Psychotherapy relationships that work III. Psychotherapy, 55(4), 303–315. https://doi.org/10.1037/pst0000193
Porges, S. W. (2007). The polyvagal perspective. Biological Psychology, 74(2), 116–143. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsycho.2006.06.009
Porges, S. W. (2026). When a critique becomes untenable: A scholarly response to Grossman et al.’s evaluation of polyvagal theory
Therapist.com. (n.d.). What is havening, and is it effective? https://therapist.com/alternative-therapy/havening
Wampold, B. E. (2015). How important are the common factors in psychotherapy? An update. World Psychiatry, 14(3), 270–277. https://doi.org/10.1002/wps.20238

Leave a Reply